This competition started in the 1905/06 season as the number of teams in county junior leagues increased. The regional County Medals competitions were introduced for teams below the top divisions in the Junior leagues or teams who were not in a league in that area of the county.

	Winners	Runners Up
1905/06	Melton Albion	Bottesford St. Mary’s
1906/07	Bottesford St. Mary’s	Stathern Olympic
1907/08	Bottesford St. Mary’s	Granby
1908/09	Melton Athletic	Oakham Town Reserves
1909/10	Stathern Olympic	Asfordby
1910/11	Stathern Olympic	Asfordby
1911/12	Rotherby & Brooksby	Eaton Rovers
1912/13	Melton Imperial	Rotherby & Brooksby
1913/14	Eaton Rovers	Asfordby

There was no Melton Medals competition between 1914/15 and 1918/19 seasons due to the First World War.

	Winners	Runners Up
1919/20	Asfordby Athletic	Melton Imperial
1920/21	Melton Imperial	Waltham
1921/22	Melton Imperial	Holwell Works
1922/23	Melton Imperial	Holwell Works
1923/24	Hose & Clawson	Holwell Works
1924/25	Clawson United	Scalford
1925/26	Somerby	Stathern Olympic
1926/27	TW Rust & Co.	Holwell Works
1927/28	Redmile	TW Rust & Co.
1928/29	Redmile	TW Rust & Co.
1929/30	Redmile	Melton St. Mary’s
1930/31	Harby	TW Rust & Co.
1931/32	Waltham	Melton Albion
1932/33	Waltham	Oakham Rovers
1933/34	TW Rust & Co.	Market Overton
1934/35	Scalford	Midland Woodworkers
1935/36	Melton Albion	Midland Woodworkers
1936/37	Waltham	Scalford
1937/38	Melton St. Mary’s	Wymondham
1938/39	Melton St. Mary’s	Stathern Olympic
1939/40	Midland Woodworkers Reserves	Stathern Olympic

The competition was once again suspended due to war between 1940 and 1946.

After the war ended the regional County Medals competitions format was changed to be a larger county wide format with the formation of the County Medals East & West in 1946.